Heart transplant list doesn’t rank kids by medical need, study finds

2024-08-05
Heart transplant list doesn’t rank kids by medical need, study finds

Revolutionizing Pediatric Heart Transplant Allocation: A Comprehensive Approach to Prioritize the Sickest Children

The current method of listing children for heart transplant does not always rank the sickest kids first, a Stanford University-led study has found. The study, published in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology, reveals that the existing waitlist system fails to consistently prioritize patients based on medical urgency, putting children's lives at risk. Experts argue that a more nuanced approach, considering a broader range of health factors, could significantly improve outcomes and reduce wait-list mortality.

Unlocking a Fairer, More Effective Pediatric Heart Transplant System

Addressing the Shortcomings of the Current Waitlist Approach

The study, led by researchers at Stanford Medicine, analyzed data from over 12,000 children under the age of 18 who were listed for heart transplants in the United States between 1999 and 2023. The findings reveal that the current waitlist system, which relies on just three broad categories of urgency, does not effectively prioritize the sickest patients.Researchers found that the medical status of children within each of the three waitlist categories (1A, 1B, and 2) varied widely, with some very sick children categorized as lower priority while less-sick children were sometimes offered donor hearts. This disconnect between a child's actual medical need and their waitlist ranking undermines the system's core purpose of ensuring the sickest patients receive transplants first.

Uncovering the Drivers of Improved Waitlist Outcomes

The study also examined the impact of waitlist rule changes implemented in 2006 and 2016, which were intended to create a more equitable system. Surprisingly, the researchers found that these changes were not directly linked to rapid improvements in waitlist mortality. Instead, the gradual decline in deaths was primarily driven by advancements in medical care, such as the increased use of ventricular assist devices and better recognition of when to list a child for transplant.Additionally, the study revealed that the gap in outcomes between patients of different races has decreased over time, a change that was associated with better overall outcomes. Researchers also noted that the gradual adoption of the practice of transplanting organs even when blood types don't match has helped reduce waitlist mortality, especially among infants with type O blood, who were previously the most challenging to match.

Towards a Continuous Allocation Score: Refining the Waitlist System

The study's findings suggest that the current waitlist system should be revised to consider a broader range of medical factors, such as kidney function, liver function, and nutritional status, to assign each child a numeric risk score. This "continuous allocation score" would replace the existing three-category system, which the researchers found to be too broad and unable to accurately reflect the true medical urgency of each patient.Experts argue that this more nuanced approach would better prioritize the sickest children who have the best chance of a successful recovery, rather than simply favoring those who have been waiting the longest. The study's authors emphasize that the revision should also account for whether a patient is healthy enough to benefit from and recover from a transplant, as some children on full life support may not survive the waitlist period or have a good outcome post-transplant.The study's findings come at a critical time, as the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS), the national nonprofit that manages organ transplants, is already in the process of developing a new allocation system for lung transplants based on a continuous score. UNOS plans to have a proposal for how hearts should be allocated ready for review in 2025, and the researchers hope their study will provide valuable evidence to support this much-needed change.

Navigating the Complexities of Pediatric Heart Transplant Allocation

The researchers acknowledge that revising the waitlist system is a complex and challenging task, as there are many factors to consider. For example, if a patient is on full life support and their organs are shutting down, they may be extremely sick and in urgent need of a transplant, but their poor health status could also mean they may not survive the surgery or have a good outcome.Balancing these competing priorities and ensuring the system is both medically sound and ethically fair is a delicate balance that the researchers believe UNOS is well-equipped to tackle. By incorporating a broader range of medical factors and using a continuous allocation score, the experts believe the revised system will be better equipped to identify and prioritize the sickest children who have the greatest chance of a successful transplant and recovery.As the healthcare community eagerly awaits the implementation of the new allocation system, the Stanford-led study serves as a critical wake-up call, highlighting the need for a more comprehensive and effective approach to pediatric heart transplant waitlisting. By prioritizing the sickest children and leveraging the latest advancements in medical care, this transformative change has the potential to save countless young lives and ensure a more equitable and life-saving organ transplant system.

Article "tagged" as:

Related Article

How to Keep Your Kitten Safe While Playing

How to Keep Your Kitten Safe While Playing

While letting your kitten play and explore is important to its mental development, you need to make sure that what it's playing with is safe.
Kitten Development From 6 to 12 Weeks

Kitten Development From 6 to 12 Weeks

Learn how kittens develop during the first 6 to 12 weeks and what signs of development you need to look out for with these tips.
5 Common Foods In Your Pantry That Are Not Safe For Your Pets

5 Common Foods In Your Pantry That Are Not Safe For Your Pets

One potato chip is not going to hurt your pet, but there are other foods that can. Learn which to avoid and some safe foods that can be used as treats.
Fleas in Dogs

Fleas in Dogs

If a dog scratches, does that mean it has fleas? These biting bugs are no fun for dogs or their owners. Learn the causes, treatment, and prevention.
Can Dogs Eat Papaya? What to Know About Sharing This Tropical Fruit With Your Pup

Can Dogs Eat Papaya? What to Know About Sharing This Tropical Fruit With Your Pup

Papaya is safe for dogs in moderation, and it can even provide some nutritional value for them. However, too much can cause digestive upset, and it's not suitable to share with dogs with certain health conditions.
Can Dogs Eat Parmesan Cheese?

Can Dogs Eat Parmesan Cheese?

It's no secret that dogs love cheese, but what kinds of cheese should you avoid? Is Parmesan cheese a good option to treat your pup to?
10 Cat Breeds That Have Blue-Colored Coats

10 Cat Breeds That Have Blue-Colored Coats

Blue cat breeds have a uniquely colored coat that makes them stand out. The eye-catching blue coat often appears light to dark grey.
Sphynx: Cat Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

Sphynx: Cat Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

The sphynx cat is a hairless cat breed known for their playful and affectionate nature. These cats do have special needs. Learn about the sphynx cat breed’s appearance, temperament, health, and care.
Border Collie: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Border Collie: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Learn about the border collie, a popular herding breed. They're a smart and energetic dog that's also a great companion to the right pet parent.
Beagle: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Beagle: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Learn about the beagle, one of the most popular dog breeds in the world. They are known for being a cheerful, comical, loud, and energetic family dog.
How to Grow and Care for Living Stones

How to Grow and Care for Living Stones

Find out how to grow living stones, unique miniature succulents that look like pebbles. This guide covers how to care for living stone plants, including watering them just right to keep them thriving.
How to Grow and Care for a Money Tree Indoors

How to Grow and Care for a Money Tree Indoors

Money trees make beautiful, easy-care houseplants. Use this guide to grow a money tree indoors.
How to Attract Bluebirds to Your Yard: 11 Must-Know Tips

How to Attract Bluebirds to Your Yard: 11 Must-Know Tips

These tips on how to attract bluebirds will help you create a welcoming habitat. Discover the best types of foods, birdhouses, water sources, and more for attracting bluebirds.
How to Propagate Clematis from Cuttings and Layering

How to Propagate Clematis from Cuttings and Layering

Learn how to propagate clematis successfully with this step-by-step guide on two different techniques.
How to Plant and Grow Black Chokeberry

How to Plant and Grow Black Chokeberry

Learn how to use and care for this low-maintenance native shrub, including planting tips and the best types of black chokeberry to grow.
This Low-Water Garden Plan Will Look Vibrant Through Droughts

This Low-Water Garden Plan Will Look Vibrant Through Droughts

This low-water garden plan will keep your plants vibrant all throughout the hot, humid summer.
This Woodland Garden Design Overflows with Shade-Loving Plants

This Woodland Garden Design Overflows with Shade-Loving Plants

Easy-care native ferns add luxurious foliage from spring to fall. Other shade-loving perennials complement the soft textures with colorful blooms.
11 Essential Tips for Growing Vegetables from Seed for Beginners

11 Essential Tips for Growing Vegetables from Seed for Beginners

These beginner-friendly tips on growing vegetables from seed will help you successfully kick off your edible garden in spring.
Should You Use Shredded Rubber Mulch in Your Garden?

Should You Use Shredded Rubber Mulch in Your Garden?

Rubber mulch is widely touted as a game changer in landscaping, but does it live up to the hype? Find out the pros and cons of using rubber mulch.
How to Plant and Grow Cattail

How to Plant and Grow Cattail

Learn to care for this easy-growing aquatic plant, including tips for pruning, propagating, and planting.